The Innocence of Islamic Jihad: True or false?

The Innocence of Islamic Jihad: True or false?

The video was uploaded at midnight July 4. As of 12:16 it had 24
views. 

    While the greater part of the video is true and
easily verifiable, it ends with two egregious errors.  Imran
Firasat allowed his optimism to overcome rational thought.  

    Islam is incapable of reform because it is
absolutist, presented as perfected and immutable. You can not improve perfection. 

    Jihad can not be removed from the Islamic doctrine
set. While Muslims are Muslims, we can not live in peace with
them.  We can live in peace with apostates or dead Muslims, but
not with living Muslims who believe in and attempt to implement Allah’s
imperatives, threat & promise. 

     Pakistan’s Brig. S.K. Malik gave us the key to
victory in page 60 of The
Quranic Concept of War: we must destroy their faith; cause
them to abandon belief in Allah, his imperative, threat &
promise. 

The Qur’an citations in the video are listed below, each linked to a
table of parallel translations. 

• 2:191
• 2:193
• 2:244
• 2:216
• 9:39
• 9:111
• 3:169
• 5:82
• 9:41
• 3:158
• 8:12
• 8:13
• 9:73
• 9:123
• 47:4
• 5:33
• 9:29
• 8:60
• 8:65
• 9:14
• 4:150
• 4:151
• 2:85
• 8:39
• 4:84
• 9:38
• 8:39
• 3:169

    The major bin Ladin quote comes from The al-Qaeda Reader.  The Shari’ah of Jihad,
including the legal definition is found in The Reliance of the
Traveller O 9.

    The most authentic traditions concerning Jihad are
found in Sahih Bukhari’s Books of Jihad, Khumus & Expedition.  The placards boasting of world
domination have their origin in three of Ibn Kathir’s Tafsirs:

• http://www.islam-universe.com/tafsir//48.49630.html
• http://www.islam-universe.com/tafsir//2.3156.html
• http://www.islam-universe.com/tafsir//3.9075.html .
  

    For more detail about Jihad, see:

• Hasan Al-Banna:  Jihad
• Jihad: The Forgotten Obligation
• Maududi: Jihad In Islam
• Ibn Taymiyyah The Religious and Mora Doctrine of Jihad
• Suhas Majumdar Jihad:
  The Islamic Doctrine of Permanent War

    While I was writing this review, the number of
viewings grew to 274, a good start considering the date and time of
release.  This video lives up to its trailer, I am satisfied with
the production quality and factual content.  I understand that
Muslims will not agree with my verdict.  I have given you the
resources you need to verify the facts and explore the context of the
quotes.